A Critical Evaluation of Gilbert Ryle’s Concept of Mind

ABSTRACT

This emerged out of the need to understand the global tension and agitations for and self expression at all levels. Such quests that have resulted in so much agitations, terrorism and even outright wars in diverse places are also a result of the great increase in human self-consciousness in recent times.

People and nations are becoming highly of pursuing their own and destinies as they deem fit without undue interference from any quarters. What are the properties of consciousness or self-consciousness?

The purpose of this work is to provide an approximately satisfactory explanation to the problem of consciousness and self-consciousness.

This is highly necessary today because the global question of terrorism and other social evils are products of diverse philosophical systems people subscribed to, and allowed to influence their attitudes to life, values, relationships and total existence.

This work reveals that man is a unified self-conscious being because self-consciousness is the exclusive feature of the human person and the relationship between mental events and physical events is not a category mistake”. Man is a very complex being, he can feign behaviours purposefully to achieve his desired goal at any point in time.

So, mental phenomena influence our behaviours, but they are not always expressible in or reducible to overt behavours.On the basis of the findings in this research it is our position here that, even if consciousness could arise from physical processes, it is not limited to it, for man is a unified self-consciousness being.

Therefore, self- consciousness is the exclusive feature of the human person which is responsible for the much increase in the global quest for freedom and all agitations for self expressions both at the individual and the national levels.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title Page .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. i
Approval Page .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ii
Certification .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. iii
Dedication .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. iv
Acknowledgment.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. v
Abstract .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. vi
Table of Contents.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. vii

CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background of Study .. .. .. .. .. .. 1
1.2 Statement of Problem… .. .. .. .. .. 2
1.3 Purpose of Study .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 2
1.4 Thesis .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 3
1.5 Scope of Study .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 3
1.6 Significance of Study .. .. .. .. .. .. 3
1.7 Research Methodology .. .. .. .. .. .. 4

CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW .. .. .. .. 6

CHAPTER THREE: GILBERT RYLE’S CONCEPT OF MIND 35

3.1 Gilbert Ryle’s Philosophy of Mind: …. .. .. .. 35
3.1.1 The Official Doctrine and Category Mistake .. .. .. 39
3.1.2 Ryle on Intelligence and Intellect .. .. .. .. .. 49
3.1.3 Ryle on Consciousness and Introspection .. .. .. .. 50
3.1.4 Ryle on Sensation and Observation.. .. .. .. .. 52
3.2 Ryle’s Theory of Action .. .. .. .. .. .. 54
3.3 Ryle’s Dispositional Theory of Belief .. .. .. .. 56

CHAPTER FOUR: A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF GILBERT RYLE’S CONCEPT OF MIND

4.1 Are Men’s Thought always Expressed in Behaviours? .. .. 62
4.2 African Concept of Man as Unified Force/being .. .. .. 64
4.3 Indeterminism in Quantum Physics …. .. .. .. 66
4.4 Dematerialization of Matter into a Common Field of Energy .. 68

CHAPTER FIVE: IMPLICATIONS OF GILBERT RYLE’S CONCEPT OF MIND FOR

5.1 The Human Person/Personal Identity .. .. .. .. .. 73
5.2 Freedom and Responsibility .. .. .. .. .. .. 79
5.3 Death and Immortality …….. .. .. .. .. .. 81
5.4 Cybernetics and Artificial Intelligence (AI) .. .. .. .. 82
5.5 Religious Experiences and Para-normals .. .. .. .. 88
5.6 Extra – Sensory Perception (ESP) .. .. .. .. .. 90
5.7 Psycho-Analysis .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 91
5.8 Epistemology and Ethics .. .. .. .. .. .. 93
5.9 The Individual and Community Relationship .. .. .. .. 94
5.10 Human and Global Development .. .. .. .. .. 95

CHAPTER SIX: THE STATE OF THE DISCOURSE AFTER RYLE’S DEATH .. 99

6.1 The Identity Theory of the Mind .. .. .. .. 100
6.2 The Functionalists Theory of the Mind .. .. .. .. 103
6.3 Instrumentalism .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 104
6.4 Connectionism.. .. .. .. .. .. .. 105
6.5 Multiple Self Theory .. .. .. .. .. .. 105
Concluding Reflections .. .. .. .. .. .. 106
BIBLIOGRAPHY- – – – – – – 110

INTRODUCTION

This work is motivated by the global quest for freedom and self expression both at the individual and the national levels. Such quests that have resulted in much tension, agitation, terrorism and outright wars in diverse places are products of the great increase in human self consciousness in recent times.

People and nations want to be themselves without undue interference from any quarter. Ordinarily people are always advised, “be yourself”. What is it to be a self? And what does it mean to be a particular self?

It is obvious that in everything we do we adopt some conception of our identity, both as persons and as an individual, whether we are called upon to articulate it or not.1

But what features are essential to being the person you are, and what features distinguish you from other persons?

Whatever our attempts to answer the questions of self identity are, they begin with a single ‘fact’, our own consciousness. But the question of consciousness remains a mystery of ‘general metaphysics’.2

It may be the most outstanding obstacle in the quest for a complete scientific understanding of the universe, inspite all the much progress already recorded. What is the nature of consciousness?

Another motivating factor for this research is the rising interest in the cognitivist theories, the cognitive science, artificial intelligence, etc which has provoked a renewed interest in the works of Gilbert Ryle especially The Concept of Mind.

For instance, Daniel Dennet,3 a former student of Ryle has provided a systematic forward to the AD.2000 edition of The Concept of Mind. Ryle, therefore, remains a significant defender of the possibility of lucid and meaningful interpretation of higher – level human activities without recourse to an abstract soul, or self consciousness.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

 Ryle, Gilbert. The Concept of Mind. London: Penguin Books, 1949. Ryle, Gilbert. Dilemmas. Cambridge: Cambridge University press, 1956.

< p>Ryle, Gilbert. “Some Problems About Thinking”, in H.E. Kiefer and M.K. Munitz (eds.)    Mind, Science and History.Albany, New York: State University press, 1970.

Ryle, Gilbert. “Autobiographical” in word, Oscar P, and Pitcher, George, eds. Ryle A Collection of Critical Essays. Garden City NY: Double day, 1970.

Ryle Gilbert. ‘Abstractions,’ Collected Papers. London: Hutchinson, 1971. Ryle, Gilbert. The Concept of Mind. Chicago: University Press, 2002.

Ryle Gilbert. Collected Essays.Vol. 1, 11 London: Hutchinson, 1971.

Ryle, Gilbert. “Imagination” in Gustafson, D.F., Essays in Philosophical Psychology. London: Macmillan and Co. Ltd, 1973.

StudentsandScholarship Team

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*