COPYRIGHT VIOLATION AND ITS EFFECT ON THE INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT IN NIGERIA


A LONG ESSAY SUBMITTED

TO THE FACULTY OF LAW

IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF BACHELOR OF LAWS (L.L.B) DEGREE IN LAW

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Title page-                                                                     i

Certification –                                                                 ii

Dedication-                                                                   iii

Acknowledgments-                                                        iv

Table of contents-                                                           v-vii

Table cases-                                                                  viii-ix

Table of statutes and conventions-                                   x-xii

List of abbreviation-                                                        xiv

Abstract –                                                                      xiv

CHAPTER ONE

GENERAL INTRODUCTION

1.1.      Background of the Study-                                    1

1.2.      Statement of the Problem-                                    3

1.3.      Research Questions-                                             3

1.4.      Objectives/Purposes of the Study-                         4

1.5       Methodology-                                                       5

1.6       Relevance of the Study-                                       5

1.7.      Scope/Delimitation of the Study-                        6

1.8.      Limitation of the Study-                                       6

CHAPTER TWO

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1.      Historical Origin of Copyright in Nigeria-           11

2.2.      Meaning and Nature of Copyright-                      13

2.3.      Copyright and its Relationship to Other Intellectual

            Property in Nigeria-                                             15

1.4       The Rationale for Law of Copyright-                   16

2.5.      Works Eligible for Copy Right-                           20

CHAPTER THREE

COPYRIGHT VIOLATION NIGERIA

3.1.      Right of the Copyright Owners-                           26

3.2.      Acts Sufficient for Copyright Infringement-       34

3.3.      Liability for Copyright Infringement                   39

3.4.      Legal Defenses for Copyright Infringement in Nigeria – 44

3.5.      Copyright Administration in Nigeria-                  48

3.6.      Remedies for Copyright Owners in Cases of Infringement – 52

CHAPTER FOUR

DEVELOPMENT OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY IN NIGERIA

4.1.      The Meaning and Nature of Intellectual Property-         59

4.2.      The Role of International Organization in the Development

            of Intellectual Property in Nigeria –                                62

4.3.      The Reason for the Persistent Decline of Intellectual

Development in Nigeria-                                                68       

4.4.      The Economic Implication of Intellectual Property

Violation in Nigeria-                                                       73

4.5.      Academic Effect of the Intellectual Property

Violation in Nigeria–                                                    77

CHAPTER FIVE

CONCLUSION

5.1       Observation-                                                                   81

5.2       Recommendation-                                                           83

5.3       Conclusion-                                                                    85

TABLE OF CASES

Adenuga        v          llesanmi press (1991) 5 NWLR 82……………..31

Akani              v.         national electric power authority (1977)3……….479

American motion picture export company ltd v. minnesota ltd  

(1981) F.H.C.L 318……………….33

Anton piller KG.       v         Manufacturing process ltd (1976)CH, 5…..57

Bekingham    v.         Hodgens (2003) ALL E.R (D) 247 C.A…….27

Bellof              v.         pressdram (1973) ALL E.R 241……………26,47

Blair               v.         Osbourne & tomkins (1971) 2 QB 78………29

BRALLER       v.         TRAILER (1830): RUSA & May………….14

Brigid foley             v.         Eliot (1982)R.P.C 433……………………..35

C.B.S Inc.& Ors        v.  Inter magnetic Co. Ltd (1987) F.H.C.L.R.31

Donoghue      v.         Allied Newpaper Ltd (1938) CH 101………14,21

Dumez (Nig) Ltd    v.            Ogboli (1973)3 U.I.L.R,311…………………54

Falcon            v.         famous player film Ltd (1914)3 K.B 474……39

Fennig Film service             v. Wolver hapton cinema (1914)3 K.B 1171…53

Francis Day  and Hunter Ltd & Ano         v.         Bron & Anor (1963)1 CH 587…39

Harims Inc Ltd          v.         v. Martins club (1933) CH 855……….31

Hawks  & sons . Ltd & sons (London) v. paramount Film service Ltd 

(1934) CH 593 …….36,47

Island record Ltd & Ors     v. pandum Technical  (1993) F.H.C.R 318……22

Jm Jonhson               v. Mobil Oil  (Nig) Ltd 1959 WNLR, 134…54

John stones   v. Benard Jones PUBLICATIONS Ltd and Anor. 

(1938)1 CH   603……………………………………………46,47

Joseph  Ikhuoria      v. Campaign service and Anor. (1986) F.H.C.R. 308…27,32 

Ladbroke (football) Ltd      v. Willliams   Hill (football)

            (1964)I W.L.R 273……………………………………………………….21,39

Machilliam & Co.        v.    coopers (1925)4 T.L.R.186………..16

Madukolu      v. Nkemdilm (1962) 2 S.C.N.R.L.R 341……………45

Master piece Investment Ltd and Anor     v. worldwide Bus8iness Media

Ltd and (1997) F.H.C.L496………………………………………31,39,46,54

Maurice Ukaoha        v.        broadbased finance Ltd and Anor (1977) 47…….32

Nicol               v.         Barranger (1917-23) MCC 219, 231…………………35

Norowzianm v.         Arks (No.2) (19990 FSR79……………………23

Offrey     v      Chief S.O Ola and Ors. Unreported. Suit No. 

Hes 23/68 of 1919…………………………………………15

Plateau publishing Co. Ltd v.  Adophy (1986)4 N,W.L.R (Pt.34) 205 

@ 255………………………………………53

Potton Ltd         v.      youkclose Ltd (1990) F.S.R, 340………………….57

R. v.     Rhodes (1899) 1 Q. B97……………………………………………..44

Ratcliffe   v.  Evans (1892)2 Q.B, 528…………………………………54

Rokana Industry PLC V.A.S Maurice and Ors (1993) F.H.C.L, 243……..58

Sales and Service Ltd(1993) FHCR…………………………………………..29

Society Bic S.A          v.         Charging       Industries      Ltd < span>     and     Anor.  (997)

F.H.C.L.R)……………………………………………………………………….29

University of London Press Ltd     v          University of Tutorial Press Ltd. 

(1916)2 CH 610…………………………………………16,22,

Walter            v.         Lane (1900) A.C. 539………………………………..23

Williams         v.         Daily Times (1996) I NWLR Pt. 129, 31……………54

Yemitam         v.         Daily Times of Nigeria (1986) 


TABLE STATUTES

Companies and Allied Matters Act Cap C. 20 Law of the Federation of Nigeria 2004

The 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended)

Copyright Act Cap. C28 Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 2004

Copyright Decree No. 611970

Criminal Code Act Cap C.35 Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 2004

The English Statute of Anne 1710

The English Copyright Design and Patent Act 1988

The Patent and Design Act Cap P.2 Laws of the Federation of Nigeria 2004

The Trade Mark Act Cap T.13 laws of the

Federation of Nigeria 2004

CONVENTIONS

The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Work1886

The Brussel Convention Relating to the Distribution of Programs-Carrying Signals Transmitted by Satellites 1974

The Geneva Convention for the Protection of Phonograms Against Unauthorized Duplication of their Phonograms 1974

The International Convention on Economic Social and Cultural Right 1966

The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property 1993

The Trade Related Aspect of Intellectual Property Right 1961

The United Nations declaration On Human Right 1948

The Universal Copyright Convention 1973

The world Intellectual Property 1967

ABSTRACT

Nigeria is an emerging country and slowly taking its place in the comity of Nations, from oil and gas to information technology. The Country is gradually carving a niche for itself as the next emerging destination after China for foreign investments. However, the country still suffers from years of neglect in the protection of intellectual property especially as it affects copyright. The copious provision of copyright Act Cap C28, LFN 2004, which embodies the current legal regime on copyright protection in Nigeria notwithstanding, the rate of copyright violation in Nigeria is still on the increase. This long essay therefore, is part of a series which outlined the various intellectual property law and practice in Nigeria with particular reference to copyright. Chapter I embodied the general introduction to the copyright protection in Nigeria. Chapter II centered on the review of the existing literature on copyright protection in Nigeria. Chapter III discussed the issues of violation of copyright in the country. Chapter IV considered the adverse effect of intellectual property decline on the National development while chapter V captioned the concluding aspect of the work including my observations and recommendation.        

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

A.C                             Appeal Cases

C.C.H.CJ                    Certified Copies of High Court Judgment

C.L.R                          Commonwealth Law Report

CH.                             Chancery

F.H.C.R                      Federal High Court Report

F.S.R                           Fleet Street Report

K.B                             Kings Bench

KSU-BJPL                 Kogi State University Bi-annual Journal of Public Law

L.F.N                          Laws of the Federation of Nigeria

N.A.F.D.A.C              National Agency for food Drug Administration and Control

Q.B                             Queens Bench

S.C.N.L.R                   Supreme Court of Nigeria Law Report

T.L.R                          Times Law Report

T.R.I.Ps                       Trade Related Aspect of Intellectual Property Right

U.I.L.R                        University of Ile Ife law Report

W.H.O                        World Health Organization

W.I.L                          Weekly law Report

W.N.LR                      Western Nigeria Law Report

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Books:

Anthony Lilly, Inside the Creative Industry (Cotal publishing 2000).

Ayn Rand, Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal: Patent and Copyright (Petal Publishing 1992).

David Bainbridge, Intellectual property (Pitman Publishing 1992).

Doris Schroeder and Peter Singe, The Prudential Reason for Intellectual property (University of Melbourne 2009).

Edward Elgar, Global Intellectual Property Law (Suthern Uma 2008).

F.O Babafemi, Intellectual Property: The law and practice of Copyright, Trade Mark patent and Industrial Design in Nigeria (Justinian Books 1994).

G.H.C Boden Nausen, Guide to the Application of the paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property as Revised at Stockholm in 1967 (World Intellectual Property Feb.1,1968).

Jeremy Philips and Allison Firth, Introduction to Intellectual Property Law (London, Dublins Edinburgh 1995).

Jide Malamo, Copyright law in Nigeria: some Critical Issues in Professor Uvieghara (ed.) Copyright Law and Administration in Nigeria (Y. Books 1992).

Laddie Prescott, Modern Law of Copyright and Design Vol. 1 (Btterworth 1995).

Miller and Davis, Intellectual Property: patent Trade Mark and Copyright (St. Paul Miniesta Publishing co. 1983) 

Obatosin Ogunkenye, Legal Remedies for Infringement of Copyright in Professor Uvi
eghara (ed.) Copyright law and Administration in Nigeria
(Y. Books) 89.

 Uvieghara, E.E, Essay on Copyright Law and Administration in Nigeria (Y. Books 1992).

 Okany, M. C, Nigeria Law of property (Fourth Dimension Publishing Co. Ltd 2000).

Alubo A.O, Contemporary Concern and Development on Copyright Law and Practice in Nigeria. The Advocate-A Journal of Contemporary Legal Issues Vol.4, Feb. 2002.

Jide Malamo, Copyright Law in Nigeria: Some Critical Issues in Professor Uvieghara (ed.) Copyright Law and Practice in Nigeria (Y. Books 1992)

Obatosin Ogunkenye, Legal Remedies for Infringement of Copyright in Professor Uvieghara (ed.) Copyright Law and Administration in Nigeria (Y. Books)89.

INTERNET

WWW.asil.org/ipl-cifm

E-Mail:ekpa shedy@rocket mail.com

Htt://en.wikipedia.org

DICTIONARY

Blacks Law English Dictionary 8th Edition.

Stroud’ Judicial Dictionary of Words and Phrases 6th Edition.

JOURNALS:

The Kogi State University Bi-annual Journal of Public Law Vol.2, 2009.

Click on the related links below and read more.

We can keep you updated on this information, please Subscribe for Free by entering your email address in the space provided.

Do you like this article? Share this article

 

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*